Handout. Liz Tinelli. Adapted from Craft of Research.
Overview: This handout distills key principles from The Craft of Research. It reframes counterargument not as a mechanical requirement (“add a counterpoint for balance”) but as a way to build a relationship with the reader. Booth et al. describe argumentation as a social interaction: a conversation in which writers anticipate readers’ questions, objections, and alternative perspectives. The handout provides language patterns, examples, and prompts that help students imagine that conversation and respond thoughtfully, using Booth’s vocabulary for acknowledgment (“Although…,” “Granted…,” “To be sure…”) and response (“However…,” “Nevertheless…”).
Uses: This handout helps students learn to strengthen their arguments by anticipating and addressing the three types of reader challenges Booth identifies: 1. Questions about the problem (Why should I care?), 2. Questions about the soundness of the claim, reasons, or evidence, and 3. Alternatives—other ways to define, explain, or solve the problem.
It is especially effective in writing courses where students are developing research-based or argumentative projects.
How do I use it in class? I ask students to identify a claim in their own draft where a skeptical reader might raise a question or objection. Working in pairs or small groups, students use the handout to name the type of reader question (problem, soundness, or alternative), draft an acknowledgement, and write a response to strengthen their reasoning.
Booth, W. (2016). The Craft of Research. 4th ed., University of Chicago Press.